The sound of laughter is universal and seems to be innate, which is often associated with humor. The incongruity theory states that humor is perceived at the moment of realization of incongruity between a concept involved in a certain situation and the real objects thought to be in some relation to the concept. Introduction although theorists concerned with onomastics do not always agree about the most basic matter of onomastics determining a precise boundary between proper names and common nouns, an average language user seldom has trouble with this distinction in everyday communication. Incongruity theory says that something causes laughter when it is a perception of something incongruous. The incongruityresolution theory another aspect of the incongruity theory suggests that reaction occurs upon realisation that two incongruous words are used relatedly suls, 1983. Incongruity theory wtf and other aberrations of comedy tuesday, september 18, 12. The theory does not really give an explanation as to why we find humour funny and can in fact be seen a theory of laughter. Faces of the international humor conference 2009 don nilsen photos debra aarons and. As previously mentioned, there are three predominant theories that encompass the early research performed on humor. May 02, 2020 incongruity countable and uncountable, plural incongruities the state of being incongruous, or lacking congruence.
A category theory perspective on compositionality and the development of cognitive capacity phillips, steven communication and categorization. Top 3 theories of attitude with diagram article shared by. Essentially, a joke should violate some sort of cultural practice or value, but at a. Mccraw 2 it took me a little while to gather my thoughts and write this paper in a manner that would truly prove my understanding of the three theories. In the importance of being earnest, how does incongruity. May 01, 2007 perspective by incongruity is a way of clouding, problematizing, and interrogating restrictive orientations through metaphorical extension 309. Pdf in the first part of this paper, i will briefly introduce the concept of incongruity and its relation to humor and seriousness, connecting the. In this paper, i will relay my understanding of the superiority theory, incongruity theory, and. Humor is irrational, which says what causes laughter is that it is a perception of something incongruouscharacterized by a lack of harmony, consistency, or compatibility with one another morreall 10. Our perception of what is funny may differ, but humor is recognized when it. Incongruity theory is the dominant approach and includes historical figures such as kant, kierkegaard, and perhaps has its origins in comments made by aristotle in rhetoric.
As this theory was created by emmanuel kant, it states that laughter is caused by something unexpected morreall, 2009. In other words, an individual has failed to meet a. Further weakening the dominance of the superiority theory in the 18th century were two new accounts of laughter which are. Theory it claims that our perception of humor is the result of the. A fourth type of theory, which takes the central feature of humor to be ambivalence, a mingling of attraction and repulsion, is of minor importance. Based on this idea, we propose that, incongruity of a textual topic can be detected by measuring two things, the statistical rarity of the topic in the given corpus and the contextual deviance of the words in the given topic measured from a universal distribution of word cousage in the society. The view that humor is produced by the experience of a felt incongruity between what we know or expectand what actually takes place. Pdf the wellknown theories are the incongruity theory, the relief theory, and the superiority theory and i only discuss the first two theories. Constructing a coactivation model for explaining humor. The incongruity theory is one of the four original theories created about humor and laughter. Congruity is a stable state and incongruity is an unstable one. Incongruity theory the incongruity theory is one of the four original theories created about humor and laughter. Pdf is the concept of incongruity still a useful construct for the. The incongruity theory was described rather badly by immanuel kant in 1790 when he said that laughter is an affectation arising from the sudden transformation of strained expectation into nothing.
To resolve or not to resolve, that is the question. Congruence general relativity, in general relativity, a congruence in a fourdimensional lorentzian manifold that is interpreted physically as a model of space time, or a bundle of world lines. The superiority theory explains humor as holding yourself to a higher standard than the thing you are laughing at monro, 1988. The present paper involves a pragmatic analysis of shakespeares measure for measure 1604. Synonyms for incongruity include discrepancy, inappropriateness, inconsistency, disparity, incompatibility, inharmoniousness, unsuitability, incongruousness. Twenty spoof ad postcards created by the adbusters media. Based on the premises of this theory, a hearer of the joke might not understand the humor in a joke if he or she cannot make the connection between the two elements. However, the incongruity theory is not without its limitations. Philosophy of humor stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Incongruity comedic theory by alexa wieczorek on prezi. Humor, according to relief theory, is used mainly to overcome sociocultural inhibitions. To resolve such incongruity, because the punch line only provides little information for resolution ruch et al. My remarks on incongruous subsumption are not intended to give. Get an answer for in the importance of being earnest, how does incongruity lend itself to humor.
Incongruity theory and the explanatory limits of reason. All or virtually all humorous situations involve the equivalent of a setup which can be considered a type of establishing operation and a punch line or trigger, by which we mean auditory or visual stimuli that supplement an individuals recent history in a specific ways. This study examined suls theories by having subjects rate. New insights into the relation between speech, labels and concepts for infants. An effective punch line must be unpredictable and take us.
Of the three, the incongruity theory seems to capture more of the examples of humor than any of its competitors. Other theories include scriptbased semantic theory argues that humor arises at the end of the joke when the audience shifts its understanding from the primary script to the opposing secondary script. He smiled bitterly at the incongruity of it, and was assailed by doubts. The next theory is the incongruity theory humor is. Incongruity definition and meaning collins english dictionary.
However, merely lacking a threat doesnt entail that. Democratizing laughter university of illinois, urbana. The art show patrons couldnt help but chuckle at the incongruity of a toilet sitting in the middle of an exhibition of renaissance paintings. According to the incongruity theory humor arises from the. Suls 1975 later proposed that familiar humor is appreciated because of the sense of competence derived from adequately remembering the joke. The theory defines laughter as a response to the perception of incongruity. Kenneth burke developed the theory of perspective by incongruity in which he claimed that oddly juxtaposed symbols influence audiences to have new perspectives by challenging their habits of thinking. The setup gets us thinking in one direction, then the punch line comes along on the brain continued on page 2 dd 1 6710 7. The incongruity theory comes into play in the above humour you have just experienced. Based on the nature of incongruity and mechanisms of resolving the incongruity of incongruity re resolution and absurd humors are entirely different, the processing of three stages would be diverse. Incongruity humor in language and beyond university of twente. Competence theory and the appreciation of novel and familiar.
Incongruity twelfth night example online definition. There are many theories of humour in addition to those we have looked at. Competence theory and the appreciation of novel and. According to suls 1972 incongruity model for the appreciation of jokes, humor with which recipients are familiar should not be perceived as funny because the ending is predictable. Developing the incongruity resolution theory graeme ritchie 1999. Reproductions supplied by edrs are the best that can be. Classes filled with relevant humor are perceived by students as interesting, high in support, and affirming. Defining humor, theories, and where is it in dance. Currently, the incongruity theory, which focuses on information processing about a humor stimulus, is regarded as the most prevalent theory explaining humor elicitation forabosco, 2008. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
The three theories of humor include the superiority theory, the incongruity theory, and the relief theory. It represents the theory because when you read the excerpt we are actually anticipating how its going to end in a logical form. Incongruity theory is restructured, the superiority theory and the relief theory can be seen as supplementary to it. When we receive jokes from others, our minds and bodies are already anticipating what is going to happen and how it is going to end. The first is incongruity theory, according to which we laugh when there is a break between what we. In the literature on humor and laughter it is customary to distinguish between three classical theories. Scissors congruence, related to hilberts third problem. This theory holds that incongruity like imbalance is unpleasant and motivates audiences to change their attitudes. According to the dictionary, then, the basic meaning of incongruous is quite simple. Oshannons book does not present or advance a theory of humor in the sense of the incongruity theory, or benign violation or the like. Incongruity means out of place something that doesnt fit in its location or situation.
The phrase theory of humor doesnt mean a set of guidelines for how to be funny or make jokes or comedies. Resolution theory takes the process onestep further by proposing that joke incongruence is not where humor is created, it is created by resolving incongruity schultz, 1976. Certainly it was an exercise in incongruity to compare these quiet, rather depressed looking people with the vision conjured up by lord johns raving lunatics, worthy of the straight jacket, or paul fileys sexless monstrosities. For instance, the benign violation theory of humor developed by a team of psychologists at the university of colorado boulder explains funny as a series nonthreatening violations of social norms source. Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. Martin eden, by jack london but he had fancied her in love with him. Theories of humor in the wider sense are attempts to solve this problem. Based on this idea, we propose that, incongruity of a textual topic can be detected by measuring two things, the statistical rarity of the topic in the given corpus and the contextual deviance.
This theory states that how much change should be there in the attitudes towards the source and the concept so that incongruity is resolved. Incongruity definition and meaning collins english. Zellers congruence, an algorithm to calculate the day of the week for any date. The incongruity of something is its strangeness when considered together with other. There are two distinct positions within the incongruity theory. Rather than revise the theory so that it made better predictions, they fiddled with the formula to make it fit the data. Incongruity theory with several varieties became the most influential predominant approach among humor scholars. If the relief theory held water, however, we might expect the crime rate to be much lower and every comedy at the cineplex to bring in blockbuster crowds.
The general theory of verbal humor, which is basically a form of appropriate incongruity theoryfails because of its formalizing aspirations. The study proposes that incongruity theory explains the mechanism of humor occurrence but superiority and relief theories provide the function or the reasons beyond the use of humor. While being a variant on the more general concepts of the incongruity theory of humor see above, it is the first theory to identify its approach as exclusively linguistic. For example, a joke becomes funny when we predict an outcome and another happens. Humor may thus for example serve to facilitate relief of the tension caused by ones fears. Coined by eagly and karau 2002, prejudice toward female leaders occurs because inconsistencies exist between the characteristics associated with the female gender stereotype and those associated with the. Incongruity theory or incongruity resolution theory is in the kernel of computational approaches to humor. Schopenhauer the ludicrous is always the paradoxical, and therefore unexpected, subsumption of an object under a conception which in other respects is different from it. In the incongruity detection stage, incongruities in incongruity resolution humor occur because of the gap or distance between the punch line and. A computational approach to detection of conceptual. Weakness of incongruity theory negative emotions like fear, disgust, and anger are reactions to what violates our mental patterns and expectations, and therefore, the mere perception of incongruity is insufficient, as it stands alone, for humor.
Congruity definition is the quality or state of being congruent or congruous. The tactic is intentional incongruity, similar to the idea of the oxymoron, placing two differing concepts together, whose pairing works to alter or extend the limitations of an orientation. On the brain and jars us into realizing there is a completely. They include the play theory, the conflict theory, the ambivalence theory, the dispositional theory, the mastery theory, the gestalt theory, the piagetian theory and the configurational theory. Four recent theories of humor, the general theory of verbal humor, conceptual integration or blending theory, benign violation theory, and falsebelief theory, all betray serious weaknesses. As a result, incongruity leads to a change of attitude. This theory postulates that humor is caused due to the playful violation of the subjective expectations of an agent. Using the three theories of humor, assess which theory best explains your sense of humor.
The reason behind selecting this play is attributed to two main points. This study examined suls theories by having subjects rate jokes on. It is the dominant theory of humor in philosophy and psychology. Incongruity theory incongruity theory suggests that humor comes from the unexpected delivery of disjointed information or surprising pairings of ideas duncan, 1985. Variants of incongruity resolution graeme ritchie 2009 pp. This study applies kenneth burkes rhetorical theory of perspective by incongruity to the adbusters anticonsumerism campaign. If someone is telling a joke that has rhythm followed by. Humor, incongruity, incongruity resolution, cognitive model. The first traces of the incongruity theory can be found in cicero and kant, but it was not until schopenhauer that the theory was fully arti2 hutcheson, f reflections upon laughter. While incongruity theory is considered as a linguistic theory, superiority is a sociological approach to humor and relief is a psychological one. As we venture into the psychology of humor, we have come across several competing theories that may or may not support each others hypothesis.
Incongruity incongruity norm violation cannot be sufficient for humour because it is found in nonhumorous contexts as well e. Humor arising from disjointed, illsuited pairings of ideas or situations or presentations of ideas or situations that are divergent from habitual customs. His grouchy compatriot schopenhauer later elaborated on this, defining humour as the incongruity between a concept and the real object to which it was to. Todays humor research draws on elements of these primary theories and remixes them. Humor has been found to enhance both creativity and learning. However, congruity theory classifies all messages as either associative or disassociative, with no provision for stronger or weaker messages. The scriptbased semantic theory of humor ssth was introduced by victor raskin in semantic mechanisms of humor, published 1985. A second improvement is that congruity theory offers a formula for predicting the direction and amount of attitude change those who are interested in the details of the formula should consult the reading list. The superiority theory is concerned with the affective response.
A role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders proposes that perceived incongruity between the female gender role and leadership roles leads to 2 forms of prejudice. Three categories of humor in latin pedagogy jiha min harvard college abstract. The incongruity theory has also a second direction, incongruityresolution theory, which is the reaction when discovering that two incongruous terms are actually related suls, 1983. Congruence manifolds, in the theory of smooth manifolds, the set of integral curves defined by a nonvanishing vector field defined on the manifold congruence general relativity, in general relativity, a congruence in a fourdimensional lorentzian manifold that is interpreted physically as a model of space time, or a bundle of world lines. Though it is not entirely flawless, incongruity theory stands as one of the most prominent accounts of amusement in the contemporary discussion of philosophy of humor. When we begin to analyze these theories and attempt to understand their hypothesis, one item we need to keep in mind is the time in which they were. The incongruity theory of curiosity postulates that humans deem the optimal presence of conceptual incongruity in their observations as \interesting. The incongruity theory suggests that humour arises when things that do not normally go together replace logic and familiarity. Journal of business and management chapman university. Focusing primarily on the object of humour, this school sees humour as a response to an incongruity, a term.
What is incongruity schopenhauers own claim for his theory is bold. Chapter 2 incongruity theory the term incongruity theory refers to a group of philosophical accounts of humor that posit the perception of incongruity as the source of amusement. The theory does not explain why messages that do not appear genuine eisenhower praising communism are ignored and unpersuasive. Top 3 theories of attitude with diagram your article library. Monros theories of humor michigan state university. The humour arises, schopenhauer claims, from the incongruity of the latter with the concept. The incongruity theory of curiosity postulates that humans deem the optimal presence of conceptual incongruity in their observations as interesting.
As i was reading breakfast of champions it seemed like the society lacked a lot of normal things. This theory states that how much change should be there in the attitudes towards the source and the concept so that incongruity is. It would be easy to propose that messages with strong arguments would produce more incongruity and therefore more attitude change than messages with weak arguments. The incongruity theory purports to define the formal object of comic amusement, which it locates in certain kinds of incongruity. May 14, 20 incongruity theory posted on may 14, 20 by kuba the incongruity theory was described rather badly by immanuel kant in 1790 when he said that laughter is an affectation arising from the sudden transformation of strained expectation into nothing. Congruity definition of congruity by merriamwebster.
1449 1359 397 1492 232 149 79 1525 1489 55 761 1315 326 995 645 492 1357 1165 344 1585 129 1289 473 1205 881 1374 880 1301 581 992 777